REPORT DIGEST

DEPARTMENT OF REHABILITATION SERVICES
ILLINOIS CENTER FOR REHABILITATION AND EDUCATION




FINANCIAL AND COMPLIANCE AUDIT
For the Year Ended:
June 30, 1997


Summary of Findings:

Total this audit 9
Total last audit 4
Repeated from last audit 3





Release Date:
July 22, 1998




State of Illinois
Office of the Auditor General

WILLIAM G. HOLLAND
AUDITOR GENERAL

Iles Park Plaza
740 E. Ash Street
Springfield, IL 62703
(217) 782-6046









SYNOPSIS

  • The Center (ICRE) did not maintain fully adequate property records. This condition has existed since 1992.
  • ICRE did not have adequate physical control over all of its property.
  • ICRE-Roosevelt did not maintain adequate control over requests for reimbursements for breakfast and lunch programs. ICRE-Roosevelt lost approximately $2,400 in reimbursements. This condition has existed since 1990.
  • ICRE did not always obtain signed contracts prior to the effective date for the performance of services. This condition has existed since 1990.







{Expenditures and Activity Measures are summarized on the next page.}


ILLINOIS DEPARTMENT OF REHABILITATION SERVICES
ILLINOIS CENTER FOR REHABILITATION AND EDUCATION
FINANCIAL AND COMPLIANCE AUDIT
For the Year Ended June 30, 1997


EXPENDITURE STATISTICS

FY 1997

FY 1996

  • Total Expenditures (All Funds)

    OPERATIONS TOTAL
    % of Total Expenditures
    Personal Services
    % of Operations Expenditures
    Average No. of Employees
    Other Payroll Costs (FICA, Retirement)
    % of Operations Expenditures
    Contractual Services
    % of Operations Expenditures
    All Other Operations Items
    % of Operations Expenditures
    GRANTS TOTAL
    % of Total Expenditures
  • Cost of Property and Equipment
  • Selected Account Balances (Locally Held Funds)
    Assets - As of June 30,
    Liabilities - As of June 30,
    Revenues
    Expenditures

$6,511,689

$6,426,804
99%
$4,320,874
67%
119
$705,351
11%
$1,003,132
16%
$397,447
6%
$84,885
1%

$9,296,375


$207,816
$4,279
$24,315
$23,845

$6,023,205

$5,925,670
98%
$4,069,516
69%
114
$657,906
11%
$895,048
15%
$303,200
5%
$97,535
2%

$9,464,678


$207,202
$4,135
$21,952
$19,482

SELECTED ACTIVITY MEASURES

FY 1997

FY 1996

  • Average Student Population
    Roosevelt
    Wood
  • Employee to Student Ratio
    Roosevelt
    Wood
  • Cost per Student
    Roosevelt
    Wood

    *Data unavailable due to change in census method.


74
250

1.27/1
1/10

$64,956
$6,096


58
*

1.56/1
*

$76,708
*

AGENCY DIRECTOR(S)
During Audit Period:
Roosevelt: Dr. Alejandro Benavides, Superintendent
Wood: Bettye Odem-Davis, Superintendent
Currently:
Roosevelt: Dr. Alejandro Benavides, Superintendent
Wood: Bettye Odem-Davis, Superintendent















Inadequate maintenance of property records















Lack of physical control over property

















Loss of federal reimbursements
























Failure to obtain signed contracts prior to the effective date

INTRODUCTION

The State Fiscal Year 1997 financial statements and accompanying notes will be the last statements prepared for the Illinois Department of Rehabilitation Services - Illinois Center for Rehabilitation and Education (ICRE). In July 1996, Governor Jim Edgar signed into law House Bill 2632 merging most of Illinois' human services functions into a new Department of Human Services (DHS) effective July 1, 1997. The Department of Rehabilitation Services transferred all of its rights, powers, duties and functions to the DHS on July 1, 1997 as prescribed by Public Act 89-507.

FINDINGS, CONCLUSIONS, AND RECOMMENDATIONS

INADEQUATE MAINTENANCE OF PROPERTY RECORDS

The Center (ICRE) did not maintain fully adequate property records.

Overall, we noted ICRE-Wood and ICRE-Roosevelt lacked segregation of duties over the maintenance of property records and did not maintain detailed records to fully support additions, deletions and transfers. In addition, the property records were not updated to reflect certain items noted as present during the physical inventory. (Finding 1, page 14) This finding has been repeated since 1992.

We recommend ICRE maintain adequate property records as required by the State Property Control Act and CUSAS.

ICRE responded it will maintain and record property as required by the State Property Control Act and CUSAS. (For previous agency responses, see Digest Footnote 1.)

LACK OF PHYSICAL CONTROL OVER PROPERTY

ICRE did not have adequate physical control over all of its property.

Overall, we noted ICRE-Wood and ICRE-Roosevelt failed to utilize transfer sheets to document movement of property. In addition, we noted property records are separated by general location but do not specify room/employee assignments. Specifically, we noted items that were not tagged or did not trace by location or tag number to the property records. (Finding 2, page 17)

We recommend ICRE maintain property as required by the State Property Control Act. Specifically, the Center should improve documentation of the transfer of property within its locations and should establish specific locations for items on the property records.

ICRE responded it will review procedures and revise them where necessary. In addition, equipment items will be properly tagged and transfers recorded timely.

LOSS OF FEDERAL REIMBURSEMENTS

ICRE-Roosevelt did not maintain adequate control over reimbursements for breakfast and lunch programs.

  • ICRE-Roosevelt did not utilize an appropriate method to count and report meals served or meals prepared and taken off the premises.
  • ICRE-Roosevelt did not verify that its application for the "Severe Need Breakfast Program" had been received and accepted by the State Board of Education. Also, ICRE-Roosevelt failed to realize that reimbursements for this program were not being received. This resulted in the loss of approximately $2,400 in reimbursements. (Finding 3, page 19)

We recommend ICRE-Roosevelt establish procedures to take an actual meal count for completion of monthly claim forms and monitor reimbursements to verify all eligible reimbursements are received. This finding has been repeated singe 1990.

ICRE-Roosevelt responded it has submitted the application for the "Severe Need Breakfast Program" and reimbursements are being monitored. In addition, ICRE-Roosevelt stated it will work with the food contractor to insure accurate meal counts are taken. (For previous agency responses, see Digest Footnote 2.)

FAILURE TO OBTAIN SIGNED CONTRACTS

ICRE did not always obtain signed contracts prior to the effective date for the performance of services. We noted the following:

  • Four contracts at ICRE-Wood were approved between 13 and 53 days after the effective date.
  • One contract at ICRE-Roosevelt was approved 30 days after the effective date. (Finding 4, page 21)

We recommend ICRE coordinate procedures with the Department of Rehabilitation Services to allow sufficient time to obtain approval prior to the effective date of the contract. This finding has been repeated since 1990.

ICRE responded it will coordinate contract activities with the Department to allow sufficient time for approval prior to the effective date. (For previous agency responses, see Digest Footnote 3.)

 

OTHER FINDINGS

The remaining findings are less significant and are being given appropriate attention by ICRE. We will review progress toward implementing these recommendations in our next audit. Responses to the recommendations were provided by Mr. James Donkin, Chief Internal Auditor for the Department of Human Services.

 

AUDITOR'S OPINION

We have stated the financial statements for the Locally Held Funds of the Illinois Department of Rehabilitation Services-Illinois Center for Rehabilitation and Education as of and for the year ended June 30, 1997 are fairly presented in all material respects.

___________________________________
WILLIAM G. HOLLAND, Auditor General

WGH:PH:ak

AUDITORS ASSIGNED

This audit was performed by the Office of the Auditor General's staff.

DIGEST FOOTNOTES

#1: INADEQUATE MAINTENANCE OF PROPERTY RECORDS - Previous Agency Responses

1996: "We concur with this finding and we are revising procedures to ensure that property records are updated and maintained on current basis.

The Business Administrator is responsible for supervising the updating of the property and equipment listing and the responsibility for entry of transactions onto the system has been assigned to the Accountant III in the Business Office.

Additionally, the Business Administrator has identified a method to list inventory by room location. This will reduce the time required to complete a physical count. This time savings will be utilized to work with DORS Central Office Staff to improve inventory record maintenance."

1994: "We concur with the finding. Extra effort needs to be made to assure all property and equipment records are completed timely and accurately at ICRE-Roosevelt and Wood. We will conduct an overall review of the equipment and property management at both locations to determine what course of action is best suited to resolve the problem. This review will be done by Center staff, Central Office Agency staff and Internal Audit staff and recommendations will be made and implemented.

Procedures have already been developed and disseminated by Central Office to all facilities for uniform property control. We will make sure that these procedures are given to the appropriate staff at ICRE. In addition, the Business Office Operating Manual (BOOM) reiterates the proper procedures for the recording of property transactions. ICRE staff will be reminded to follow BOOM procedures."

1992: "The School concurs."

#2: LOSS OF FUNDS THROUGH FEDERAL REIMBURSEMENT-Previous Agency Responses

1996: "We concur with this finding and action is being taken to correct this problem. The Business Administrator is responsible for ensuring the accurate and timely filing of Federal reimbursement claim forms. He will review and approve (in writing) all forms prior to submission and he will also maintain a file of completed forms."

1994: "We concur with this finding. However, the problems reported were for the early part of the audit period and procedures have been implemented to prevent future occurrences. An overall review of the Center's National School Lunch Program, conducted on December 6, 1994 by the Illinois State Board of Education, was found to be in compliance with their requirements.

The Center has instituted internal control procedures to ensure that all future claim forms will be accurately completed, properly submitted and requested reimbursements tracked to avoid recurrence of this problem. Staff are in the process of researching whether the reimbursements for 7/92, 6/93, 7/93 and 8/93 are still recoverable. If so, these billings will be resubmitted to collect these funds."

1992: "The School concurs and accepts the recommendation."

1990: "We concur with the finding. Procedures will be augmented to ensure the timely submission of the federal grant application."

#3: PERFORMANCE OF CONTRACTS PRIOR TO OBTAINING SIGNATURE - Previous Agency Responses

1996: "We concur with this finding and will initiate contract processing early enough to allow sufficient time to obtain appropriate signatures prior to the performance of the contracts.

ICRE-Roosevelt will initiate the contract process for FY98 during January 1997. This will allow sufficient lead time to allow the contracts to be completed and filed prior to the start date of the contracts. Additionally, the Business Administrator will work with Central Office staff to avoid late signing of contracts.

At ICRE-Woods, a breakdown in communications, after a change in contract procedures, contributed to the late filing of contracts. Procedures between ICRE-Woods/Bureau of Blind Service and Central Office have been established regarding communication of procedural changes. This has resolved this issue. Additionally, the Business Administrator will work with Central Office staff to avoid late signing of contracts."

1994: "We concur with the finding. The Agency has implemented a contract tracking system that allows us to follow contracts and monitor their progress. The Agency will continue to monitor contract progress and work toward reducing or eliminating this problem. Additionally, we will work with staff and contractees to aid in the timely completion and submission of contracts.

While we will continue to work on improvement in this area, there will always be some circumstances whereby contracts will be filed late. CUSAS provides for the filing, obligation and payment of contracts by both parties after the effective date by use of affidavits."

1992: "The Department concurs and will commence a comprehensive review of relevant planning procedures."

1990: "We concur with the statement that signing a contract prior to commencement of work is a sound business practice. However, we did follow affidavit procedures which were designed by the Comptroller to deal with situations where this is not possible."

"We are installing procedures developed to speed up contract processing."