REPORT DIGEST FINANCIAL
AUDIT For the Year Ended: June 30, 2008 Release Date: April 14, 2009
State of
Office of the Auditor General WILLIAM G. HOLLAND AUDITOR GENERAL
To obtain a copy of the
Report contact: Office of the Auditor
General
(217) 782-6046 or TTY (888)
261-2887 This Report Digest and Full
Report are also available on the worldwide web at www.auditor.illinois.gov |
INTRODUCTIONThis digest covers our financial audit of the Illinois Student Assistance Commission for the year ended June 30, 2008. A compliance examination covering the year ended June 30, 2008 will be issued at a later date. ¨ The Commission did not have adequate internal controls over financial reporting for its securities lending transactions. ¨ The Commission did not have adequate collateral to cover 100% of its deposit balances that exceeded FDIC insured amounts and investments in a single issuer exceeded investment policy limits.
{Expenditures
and Activity Measures are summarized on the reverse page.} |
FINANCIAL
AUDIT
For The Year
Ended June 30, 2008 (Amounts Expressed In Thousands)
(Certain FY2007 information has been reclassed to conform to the FY2008 presentation)
FINANCIAL OPERATIONS (All
Funds) |
FY 2008 |
FY 2007 |
GOVERNMENTAL ACTIVITIES Program revenues: Operating grants and contributions......................... Program expenses: Scholarships, awards and grants............................. Interest................................................................ Governmental activities, net (expenses)........................ BUSINESS-TYPE ACTIVITIES Program revenues: Charges for services............................................. Operating grants and contributions......................... Program expenses: Student loan purchase program.............................. Prepaid tuition....................................................... Scholarships, awards and grants............................. Loan guarantee program....................................... Business-type activities, net (expenses).................. Program
activities, net................................. GENERAL REVENUES Appropriations............................................................ Investment income...................................................... Special item – sale of loan portfolio.............................. Other…..................................................................... Change in
net assets.................................... |
$ 5,052 429,558 569 430,058 (425,006) 114,445 131,839 246,284 101,174 73,559 - 226,553 401,286 (155,002) (580,008) 429,309 2,579 (10,855) (4,702) 416,331 $ (163,677) |
$ 5,142 402,384 569 402,953 (397,811) 227,552 414,999 642,551 303,817 61,641 53,306 225,843 644,607 (2,056) (399,867) 397,650 1,056 (17) (89) 398,600 $ (1,267) |
SELECTED BALANCE SHEET ACCOUNTS |
FY 2008 |
FY 2007 |
Cash and cash equivalents................................................. Investments and marketable
securities................................ Securities lending
collateral................................................ Student loans receivable,
net Other receivables.............................................................. Notes receivable............................................................... Tuition & accretion
payable............................................... Revenue bonds payable and
lines of credit.......................... Securities lending
collateral obligation................................. Total assets...................................................................... Total liabilities................................................................... Total net assets................................................................. |
$ 134,374 987,650 167,529 1,135,038 63,829 98,838 1,102,406 1,270,211 170,776 2,603,605 2,589,606 13,999 |
$
222,587 1,024,630 - 3,414,956 131,743 87,587 956,201 3,674,744 - 4,897,236 4,767,522 129,714 |
AGENCY DIRECTOR |
|
|
Controls over financial reporting were
not adequate
Collateral investments, obligations, and
losses were not recorded
Disclosures were not made
Management stated that information was
not received timely
Controls over reporting investment
transactions need improvement
The Commission accepted our
recommendation
Deposits were not collateralized
Investments exceeded investment policy
limits
10% invested in a single issuer limited
by policy to 5%
$5 million deposit balance
uncollateralized
Management stated that errors were made
Recommended improved monitoring of
deposits and investments
The Commission accepted the auditor’s
recommendation |
FINDINGS, CONCLUSIONS, AND RECOMMENDATIONSSECURITIES
LENDING PROGRAM NOT ACCOUNTED FOR PROPERLY The Illinois Prepaid
Tuition Program (Program) of the Illinois Student Assistance Commission
(Commission) did not have adequate internal controls over financial reporting
for its securities lending transactions. The Commission implemented
a securities lending program in fiscal year 2008. The Commission did not record its $168
million in securities lending collateral investments or $171 million in
liabilities related to securities lending as of June 30, 2008, or the
associated $3 million unrealized loss incurred for the fiscal year. In addition, the draft financial statements
provided to the auditors did not have the required securities lending
disclosures. According
to Commission management, the Commission receives information on a monthly
basis from the custodial bank. The final information regarding impairment of
the value of the securities lending collateral was received by the Commission
only after year-end in August 2008. (Finding 1, page 76) We recommended the
Commission improve its controls so that it timely obtains all relevant
investment information necessary to properly record and disclose of all
material investment transactions in the Program’s annual financial
statements. The
Commission accepted our recommendation and indicated it had implemented
additional controls to ensure that all material transactions and disclosures
are properly recorded on the financial statements on a timely basis. INVESTMENT POLICIES
NOT FOLLOWED The Illinois Designated
Account Purchase Program (IDAPP) does not have adequate collateral to cover
100% of its bank deposit balances that exceed FDIC insured amounts, and
investments in a single issuer exceeded investment policy established limits.
IDAPP was in violation of
its current investment policy restricting investments in a single issuer to
no more than 5% of the total investment portfolio of the agency. IDAPP held over $5.6 million in commercial
paper issued by a financial institution.
This investment was approximately 10% of IDAPP’s total investment
balance at its fiscal year-end. In addition, during
testing of cash and investments, a lack of sufficient collateral for deposits
in excess of FDIC insured amounts was noted.
IDAPP has an uninsured uncollateralized deposit balance of
approximately $5 million at June 30, 2008, consisting of 2 locally held
accounts in violation of the State Officers and Employees Money Disposition
Act (Act). According
to Commission management, one of the bank accounts was set-up incorrectly,
resulting in the balances being uncollateralized. An additional $4.7
million in a different bank was set up as a collateral account based on a
contractual agreement. It was an oversight that a reciprocal
collateralization was not provided (by the bank) for the funds that IDAPP
provided to the bank as collateral.
The $5,612,565 of commercial paper at another financial institution
was also set-up in error. (Finding 3, pages
78-79)
We recommended IDAPP obtain sufficient
collateral to cover uninsured deposit balances at each applicable bank. In addition, IDAPP should improve
monitoring controls over deposit balances and to ensure that it adheres to
its investment policy. The Commission accepted our recommendation and stated that it had subsequently reduced its commercial paper investment to $3.5 million and invested in treasury bills. The $4.7 million uncollateralized deposit at Guarantee Bank has now been closed and other deposits are now fully collateralized. OTHER
FINDINGS The remaining findings concern other insufficient controls over financial reporting. We will review progress toward implementation of all recommendations during the next audit. AUDITORS’ OPINIONOur auditors stated the June 30, 2008 financial statements of the Illinois Student Assistance Commission are fairly presented in all material respects. ____________________________________ WILLIAM G. HOLLAND, Auditor General WGH:JAF:pp SPECIAL ASSISTANT AUDITORS
Our special assistant auditors for this audit were McGladrey & Pullen, LLP. |